Dating advice, checked against the research

Valentine's pick up lines and roses are red poems

Original Valentine's Day pick up lines and roses are red rhymes for texts and cards: new match, flirty chat or partner, with a research check on cheesy.

The Mocha team6 min read

A good Valentine's pick up line is a warm sentence that ends in something the other person can answer. Cheesy is fine when it is clearly a joke, and weaker when it is trying to sound smooth. Below are original lines and roses are red rhymes, grouped by who they are for: someone you just matched with, someone you have been texting, and a long term partner you are writing a card for.

Cheesy versus plain: what research there is

The research is old and narrow, but it points one way. In 1989 Michael Cunningham ran two field experiments in singles bars and one in a laboratory. When a man approached women with one of six opening lines, the cute-flippant ones drew significantly more negative responses than direct or innocuous lines, and in the second bar experiment women again reacted worst to them, while men responded more positively than women whatever the line. That is an in person study from 1989, not a study of text messages, so use it as a nudge rather than a rule. Our page on pick up lines goes through it in more detail.

A second finding applies to any message. Karen Huang and colleagues found that people who ask more questions, especially follow-up questions, are better liked, and that people do not expect it to work. So the shape we suggest for a message is a light joke followed by a question about the other person.

Cards still matter to many people. The National Retail Federation found greeting cards among the top planned gifts in the US, at 41 percent of consumers in 2026, and YouGov found that 43 percent of British adults who celebrated in 2024 gave or received a card.

For a new match

These are meant to be sent as a first or early message on or around the day, with no pressure attached.

  • "Happy Valentine's Day, in the least pressure way possible. What are you doing tonight besides ignoring everyone's couple photos?"
  • "No pressure Valentine's question: dinner out, takeout on the couch, or skip the holiday entirely?"
  • "I'm told today is for flowers and candy. I'd settle for your go-to karaoke song."
  • "Matching on a holiday that involves this much chocolate feels like a sign. What's your favorite kind?"
  • "Valentine's Day match, so I'll keep it seasonal: what's the worst card you've ever been given?"
  • "Happy Valentine's Day. I'll bring the bad puns if you bring the good ones."
  • "Pretty sure there's a rule that I have to ask on Valentine's Day: want to get tacos this week and ignore the holiday together?"

Two cautions. Do not send a line that comments on someone's body, and do not copy and paste the same message to everyone; people can tell, and it takes away the one thing a line can do, which is show that you read their profile. Add one detail from it: "I saw you like hiking. What's the best trail you've done?"

For someone you have been talking to

A little more heat, still easy to answer.

  • "You're the reason I checked my phone this morning, and I'd like that on the record."
  • "I found a candy heart that says TEXT ME. Felt redundant. Dinner Thursday instead?"
  • "My Valentine's plan is simple: you, me, and one very long argument about the best movie sequel."
  • "I'm not great at grand gestures, but I'm excellent at remembering what you order. Table for two?"
  • "Fair warning: I think you're cute and I'm going to be a little dumb about it."
  • UK: "I could book somewhere posh, or we could find a proper pub with a fire. I think I know which one you'd pick."

Roses are red, originals

The rhyme is old. According to Wikipedia's summary, a secondary source, its imagery goes back to Edmund Spenser's The Faerie Queene in 1590, a close ancestor of the modern verse appears in the eighteenth century nursery collection Gammer Gurton's Garland, and it has spawned many humorous variants since. Our page on Valentine's poems reads the early versions directly. The form is four lines, the first two more or less fixed, the last two yours. The trick is to make the third line specific and the fourth a small surprise. Each rhyme below is written out as one line; break it after each comma when you copy it into a card.

  • New match: Roses are red, I'm free after three, there's a cafe on Main Street, and the coffee's on me.
  • New match: Roses are red, the salsa is hot, I'd like to take you to my favorite spot.
  • Someone you are seeing: Roses are red, violets are blue, I ate the last chocolate, but I saved the next one for you.
  • Long term partner: Roses are red, the dishes can wait, you still make me laugh, and I still think you're great.
  • Long term partner: Roses are red, violets are blue, thanks for the years, and the leftovers too.
  • UK: Roses are red, it's raining in Leeds, you're still the only forecast I need.

For a long term partner

A card is a better home for sincerity than a text. These are short enough to sign:

  • "Still picking you, even on the days we disagree about the thermostat."
  • "You make ordinary Tuesdays the good ones."
  • "You still laugh at the story I've told you forty times. I'm keeping you."
  • "Thank you for the small things nobody notices but me."
  • "Happy Valentine's Day. Same couch, same blanket, still the best seat in the house."

If a line feels like something you would not say aloud, change it until it is. A shorter card in your own voice beats a longer one that sounds like a store.

Sending it

Timing is simple. For a new match, send it on or just before the day, not at midnight, and make room for a no reply. For a partner, hand over the card with a plan, not as a substitute for one. If the line is a pun, say it with a smile; if it is sincere, say it plainly. Our pages on pick up lines, funny chat up lines and Valentine's date ideas cover more.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good Valentine's pick up line?
One that is warm, specific and easy to answer. 'No pressure Valentine's question: dinner out, takeout on the couch, or skip the holiday entirely?' works better than a pun because it gives the other person something to reply to. In a 1989 field study by Cunningham, cute-flippant openers drew more negative responses than direct or innocuous ones, so when in doubt be friendly and plain.
How do you write a funny roses are red poem?
Keep the first two lines as they are and make the last two specific: a real habit, a real food, a real argument. 'Roses are red, violets are blue, I ate the last chocolate, but I saved the next one for you' works because the third line is a small confession. Say it out loud once; if the rhythm stumbles, change the last word.
What do you write to a new match on Valentine's Day?
Acknowledge the day lightly, then ask something about them. Skip anything that implies you are already a couple. 'Happy Valentine's Day, in the least pressure way possible. What are you doing tonight besides ignoring everyone's couple photos?' is a typical shape: a joke at the day's expense, then a question.

Sources

  1. Cunningham (1989), Reactions to heterosexual opening gambits, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 15(1) (SAGE record) Abstract read on October 9, 2026; the full text was not read. Supports two field experiments in singles bars and one laboratory experiment; in Experiment 1 a man used one of six lines on women and cute-flippant lines drew significantly more negative responses than direct and innocuous ones; in Experiment 2 women again responded more negatively to cute-flippant lines, and men responded more positively than women regardless of the line. A 1989 in person study, not a study of text messages.
  2. Huang, Yeomans, Brooks, Minson and Gino (2017), It doesn't hurt to ask: question-asking increases liking, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (Harvard Business School copy) Full text read October 9, 2026. Supports people who ask more questions, particularly follow-up questions, being better liked by conversation partners in three studies, a speed dating result that is correlational, and people not anticipating that asking questions increases liking.
  3. Wikipedia: Roses are red Read October 9, 2026. Secondary source, used only for the outline of the rhyme's history. Supports the imagery appearing in Spenser's The Faerie Queene (1590), a version close to the modern one in the nursery collection Gammer Gurton's Garland, the modern four line form, and the many humorous and parodic variants.
  4. National Retail Federation (January 27, 2026), Valentine's Day spending expected to reach new records Read October 9, 2026. Supports greeting cards being among the top planned Valentine's gifts in the US, at 41 percent of consumers.
  5. YouGov (February 23, 2024), 6 key takeaways from post Valentine's Day survey in Britain Read October 9, 2026. Supports 43 percent of British adults who celebrated Valentine's Day 2024 having given or received a card.