Greatest pick up lines: the ones that get a reply
Smooth and flirty pick up lines for apps, bars and a crush, sorted by situation and tested against the research on direct versus cute openers.
The greatest pick up lines, as people search for them, are not the cleverest. They are the ones that say you are interested, say something true about the moment, and end in a question the other person can answer in one line. No study ranks individual lines, so nobody can honestly name a winner. What there is points one way: direct and light beats cute and flippant.
What the research says
In 1989 Michael Cunningham ran two field experiments in bars and one in a laboratory, using opening lines he classed as direct, innocuous or cute-flippant. In the first, a man approached women at a singles bar with one of six lines, and the cute-flippant lines drew significantly more negative responses than the other two kinds. In the second, male and female experimenters approached patrons of the opposite sex, and women again responded more negatively to the cute-flippant ones. Men responded more positively than women whatever the line. The experimenters also touched half the people they approached while delivering the line, and the touch made no significant difference, which is one more reason to keep your hands to yourself.
It is a single study in American bars in the late 1980s, so treat it as a pointer rather than a rule. It also stops at the first sentence. Whether a conversation follows depends on what you ask next and whether you listen to the answer, which our first date questions page covers in detail.
One more finding takes the pressure off the opener itself. Nicholas Epley and Juliana Schroeder asked commuters on trains and buses either to talk to someone near them or to keep to themselves. Those who talked reported a more positive journey, and a no less productive one. Other people, asked to predict the result, expected the opposite, partly because they underestimated how interested others would be in talking. Saying hello usually costs less than it feels as if it will.
Lines by situation
The type column below is our own labeling using Cunningham's three categories, not a score from his study.
| Where | Line | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Bar or party | "Sorry, I'm terrible at this. I'm Tom, and I'd like to buy you a drink if you're up for it." | Direct |
| Bar or party | "I've been trying to figure out for ten minutes how to come over without it being weird. Is it weird?" | Direct, with a laugh at yourself |
| Bar or party | "The bartender swears by the margaritas here. Have you tried one?" | Innocuous |
| Friend's party | "How do you know Priya? I need to know whether to be nice about her cooking." | Innocuous, with a hook |
| Work or class | "I keep finding reasons to walk past your desk and I've run out. Coffee on Thursday?" | Direct |
| Work or class | "Unrelated to work: what's the last thing you watched that you'd actually recommend?" | Innocuous |
| App | "You said you're ranking taco spots. I have strong opinions about al pastor. Where's number one?" | Innocuous, specific |
| App | "Your third photo, is that Pikes Peak? I hiked it in the rain last spring and I have opinions about the donuts at the top." | Innocuous, specific |
| App, in the UK | "You said you're ranking Sunday roasts. I've got strong views on the Yorkshire. Where's number one?" | Innocuous, specific |
| App, in the UK | "Your third photo, is that Snowdon? I did it in the rain last spring and I have opinions about the café at the top." | Innocuous, specific |
Smooth versus flirty
Smooth is a clear statement with no pressure: "I'd rather say hello than wonder." It works because it is easy to say no to, and so easy to say yes to.
Flirty is cheekier, and it lands only once there is a conversation to be playful in. "Fair warning, I'm competitive about bar trivia. Which team are you on, so I know who I'm beating?" is a good second message and a risky first one. The same goes for teasing about a typo or a slow reply: it needs a reply history before it reads as warm.
Cheesy lines ("Are you a parking ticket? Because you've got fine written all over you") would sit in the cute-flippant group by our labeling. They can be fun when both people are in on it, which is why they are worth sending once you have already made each other laugh, and a poor choice as a cold opener.
On apps, the bar is higher
Pew Research Center's 2023 report on online dating, based on a survey of 6,034 US adults in July 2022, found that among current or recent online daters, 54 percent of women had felt overwhelmed by the number of messages they received, against a quarter of men. So a generic line drops into a crowded inbox, and anything that refers to something in the person's profile stands out simply by being proof that you read it.
The same report found that 56 percent of women under 50 who have used dating sites or apps had been sent a sexually explicit message or image they did not ask for, and 43 percent had had someone keep contacting them after saying they were not interested. Whatever you send, make sure nothing about it reads as the start of either. One unanswered message is an answer.
For more on opening messages that give the other person something to answer, see first messages that get a reply. For the science and math variety there is a page of nerdy pick up lines, and for lines aimed at men, pick up lines for him.
What to skip
- Anything about their body. It tells them what you noticed first and nothing about them.
- Negging. A backhanded compliment is a cute-flippant line with an edge. Nobody has tested it in the study above, but if harmless cute lines did worse than direct ones, a barbed one is unlikely to do better.
- Copy and paste. On an app, people can tell, and it costs you the one advantage of a message, which is that it can be about them.
- Three questions at once. Send one. Answer it yourself as well, so it reads as a conversation and not a form.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best pick up line?
Do pick up lines actually work?
What is a smooth pick up line for a crush?
Are flirty pick up lines safe to send on apps?
Sources
- Cunningham (1989), Reactions to heterosexual opening gambits, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin Abstract read on October 8, 2026; the publisher's page was not opened. Supports the two field experiments and one laboratory experiment, the direct, innocuous and cute-flippant categories, Experiment 1 (a man using one of six lines on women at a singles bar, cute-flippant lines drawing significantly more negative responses), Experiment 2 (male and female experimenters, women again more negative to cute-flippant lines, men more positive than women whatever the line), and touching half the subjects having no significant effect.
- Pew Research Center (2023), Key findings about online dating in the U.S. Read October 8, 2026. Supports the survey of 6,034 U.S. adults (July 5 to 17, 2022), 54 percent of women among current or recent online dating users feeling overwhelmed by the number of messages against a quarter of men, and, among women under 50 who have used dating sites or apps, 56 percent having been sent a sexually explicit message or image they did not ask for and 43 percent having had someone keep contacting them after they said they were not interested.
- Epley and Schroeder (2014), Mistakenly seeking solitude, Journal of Experimental Psychology: General (Europe PMC record) Abstract read on October 8, 2026. Supports the finding that commuters on trains and buses told to connect with someone near them reported a more positive, and no less productive, experience than those who stayed disconnected, while separate participants predicted the opposite, partly because they underestimated others' interest in connecting.