Best dating profile photos: why someone else should pick
In one study, photos of you picked by other people made a better first impression than the ones you picked. How to use that, and where it stops.
The best dating profile photos are recent, show your face clearly, and are chosen by someone other than you. That last point is not folk wisdom. In a 2017 study, photos of people chosen by others created more favorable first impressions than the photos those same people picked for themselves, and in the larger of its two experiments the gap was widest for dating profiles. So this page does not give you a list of photo rules. It gives you a way to have your pictures for a dating profile chosen by other people, and is honest about what the research measured.
The study: other people picked better photos of you
David White, Clare Sutherland and Amy Burton collected 12 Facebook photos each from 102 university students. Every photo had to show the face clearly, facing the camera and not hidden by sunglasses, hair or hands. The students then said which of their 12 they would most and least like to use on Facebook, on a professional site such as LinkedIn, and on a dating site such as Match.com. In a second step, people who did not know them made the same choices for them. Raters recruited online, who knew none of the faces, then scored each photo for impressions such as attractiveness, trustworthiness, confidence and competence.
Two results came out across the two studies, which involved 610 participants in all:
- People are good at matching photos to context. The choices for dating sites leaned toward photos rated more attractive, and the choices for professional sites toward photos rated more competent. Nobody needed to be told.
- Other people did it better. Images chosen by other people gave the online raters more favorable impressions than images people chose of themselves. In the first study the gap showed up only for professional sites; in the second, more sensitive study, it appeared on all three kinds of site and was largest for dating.
One detail matters for dating. The advantage of other people's choices came from impressions of trustworthiness and competence; for attractiveness the difference was not significant. So the evidence is that someone else is likely to pick a photo that makes you look more trustworthy and capable, not necessarily better looking.
The authors' practical conclusion is short: if you want to put your best face forward, ask someone else to choose it. They conclude that self-perception limits the impressions our own choices create, but they leave the exact mechanism open: a general tendency to see ourselves favorably does not fit their results neatly, and they suggest that familiarity with a face may make its photos harder to tell apart.
Why one photo is never the whole story
A second paper from the same research group explains why choosing matters so much. Rob Jenkins and colleagues collected many internet photos of the same people and found that viewers who did not know them often judged two photos of one person to be two different people, while people who knew them identified the same photos without error. In their fourth experiment, the differences in attractiveness between photos of one person were larger than the differences between different people.
Put plainly: depending on the photo, you can look like a different person, and a more or less attractive one. That is the range your choice is selecting from.
And the photo still has to be you
Picking the most flattering image can go too far. Jeffrey Hancock and Catalina Toma, then at Cornell, recruited 54 people using four mainstream dating sites, photographed them in the lab, and asked 50 student judges to compare each main profile photo with the lab picture. The daters rated their own photos as relatively accurate. The judges rated 31.5 percent of them below the midpoint of the accuracy scale. Women's photos in the sample were judged less accurate than men's and were more often older, retouched or taken by a professional. Men's lower scores were linked mainly to hair and age.
The two studies pull in different directions, and both matter. You want the most favorable photo that is still an accurate picture of you now.
Do you need a photoshoot for your dating profile pictures?
Probably not, in our view. No study we found compared photos from a professional dating photographer with good amateur ones, so nobody can promise that a photoshoot brings more matches. What the research does suggest is that the person holding the camera matters more than the camera.
Nicole Krämer and colleagues at the University of Duisburg-Essen showed 297 people a Facebook profile of one of six actors. In one version the pictures were selfies; in the other, the same actor in the same pose was photographed by the experimenters, on an ordinary smartphone. People in the selfies were rated less trustworthy, less socially attractive and more narcissistic. Physical attractiveness did not differ. The effects were small to moderate, the sample was mostly young, and the authors themselves ask for the study to be repeated. Still, the photos that did better were not professional. Someone else pressing the button was enough.
A photoshoot does give you one real advantage: choice. Because one person's photos vary so much, as Jenkins and colleagues found, a session with dozens of frames widens the range you pick from. The catch is accuracy: in Hancock and Toma's sample, the women's photos, judged less accurate than the men's, were also more often retouched or taken by a professional.
Our suggestion: ask a friend to photograph you in daylight in two or three places, take plenty, and have someone else choose. If you hire a photographer anyway, the same rules apply.
A selection method you can do this evening
- Collect twelve to fifteen recent photos. Use the White study's criteria as a filter: face clearly visible, looking roughly toward the camera, nothing covering it. Discard anything you would have to explain on a first date.
- Ask two people to choose, separately. Ask each to pick the three they would use on a dating profile, without seeing the other's picks. In the study the choosers did not know the people in the photos, so one person who knows you less well, a coworker rather than your closest friend, is closer to the design.
- Lead with the overlap. A photo both people picked goes first. If there is no overlap, use each person's first choice.
- Run the accuracy check. For each chosen photo ask: would someone meeting me next week recognize me from this? If the honest answer is "from a few years ago", replace it.
- Do not overrule the choosers on the first photo. That is where the study found the self-selection gap. Adjust the order of the rest if you like.
What the research does not tell you
White's raters judged impressions from photos. They did not send messages, go on dates or decide whom to contact, so nobody has shown that other-chosen photos lead to more matches. The choosers in the study did not know the faces; friends may have their own biases, which nobody has tested. All the photos came from Facebook, which the authors flag as a limitation. Hancock and Toma's sample was 54 people recruited in the New York area, in a paper published in 2009.
One finding from real dating behavior is blunt, though. In Elizabeth Bruch's study of 1,855 New York users of a subscription dating site, both men and women were roughly 20 times less likely to open a profile that had no photo at all, even after accounting for everything else on the profile. Before you worry about which photo, have one.
Frequently asked questions
Why are you bad at picking your own photo?
How many photos should a profile have?
Do group photos hurt?
Should you hire a dating profile photographer?
Sources
- White, Sutherland and Burton (2017), Choosing face: the curse of self in profile image selection, Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications Full text read October 7, 2026. Supports the 12 Facebook photos each from 102 students, the photo criteria, the choice of images for Facebook, professional and dating sites, the 160 online raters in the calibration experiment, the two studies totalling 610 participants, people choosing images that fit each context, other-selected images giving more favorable impressions than self-selected ones (first study: professional sites only; second study: all three contexts, largest effect for dating, carried by trustworthiness and competence with no significant benefit for attractiveness), the authors leaving the mechanism open, the recommendation to let someone else choose, and the limitation that all photos came from Facebook.
- Hancock and Toma (2009), Putting your best face forward: the accuracy of online dating photographs, Journal of Communication (Stanford Social Media Lab copy) Full text read October 7, 2026. Supports the 54 heterosexual daters (27 women, 27 men) on four mainstream sites, the lab photograph used for comparison, the 50 student judges, daters rating their own photos as relatively accurate, 31.5 percent of photos rated below the midpoint for accuracy, and women's photos being more often older, retouched or professionally taken.
- Jenkins, White, Van Montfort and Burton (2011), Variability in photos of the same face, Cognition (Europe PMC record) Abstract read on October 7, 2026; the full text is behind the Elsevier paywall. Supports viewers who did not know the person perceiving photos of one person as different people, familiar viewers identifying the same photos perfectly, and variability in attractiveness within one person's photos exceeding the variability between different people.
- Bruch, Feinberg and Lee (2016), Extracting multistage screening rules from online dating activity data, PNAS Full text read October 7, 2026. Supports profiles without a photo being roughly 20 times less likely to be browsed by both men and women, after controlling for the other attributes in the model, among 1,855 New York area users of a subscription site.
- Krämer, Feurstein, Kluck, Meier, Rother and Winter (2017), Beware of selfies: the impact of photo type on impression formation based on social networking profiles, Frontiers in Psychology Full text read October 16, 2026. Supports the online experiment with 297 participants, the Facebook profile mockups of six actors shown either in selfies or in photos taken by the experimenters on a smartphone, with the same pose in both, people in selfies being rated less trustworthy, less socially attractive and more narcissistic, no difference in physical attractiveness, small to moderate effect sizes, a mostly young sample, and the authors' call for replication.