Dating culture by country, from the official figures

Dating a Pisces: horoscope claims against the evidence

What the Pisces horoscope says, who believes in star signs, how guidebooks rate Pisces with Gemini, Scorpio and Virgo, and what studies found.

The Mocha team6 min read

Dating a Pisces means, in horoscope terms, dating someone born between about February 20 and March 20: a water sign said to be empathic, sensitive and emotional. The sign explains less than the belief in it. Just over one in four American adults say they believe in astrology, and 43% of women under 50, but studies that test signs against personality or against whom people marry find nothing. This page covers the claims, who actually believes them, how the guidebooks rate the Pisces pairings people look up (Pisces with Gemini, Scorpio and Virgo), and what the evidence says about each.

The last sign of the wheel

Wikipedia's chart of the Western signs lists Pisces as the twelfth and last sign, water in the mutable mode, ruled by Jupiter in classical astrology and by Neptune since the 20th century, with Virgo as its opposite. Water is glossed as emotion, empathy and sensitivity, the mutable mode as adaptability and flexibility. Combine the two and the horoscope Pisces follows: someone who absorbs the moods around them and bends to fit. Chinese participants in the 2020 study by Jackson Lu and colleagues gave the sign a darker word, "moody", which made up 30% of the adjectives they listed for it, synonyms included. The paper explains several signs' stereotypes by their Chinese names but does not explain this one.

Who believes in this

In a Pew Research Center survey of 9,593 US adults in October 2024, 27% said they "believe in astrology (the position of the stars and planets can affect people's lives)", not significantly different from the 29% who said so in 2017. The split is sharp: 43% of women aged 18 to 49 said they believe, against 20% of men in that age group. Twenty percent of adults said they use astrology, tarot or fortune tellers mostly "just for fun", and 10% because they believe the practices give helpful insights. Only 1% said they rely a lot on them for major life decisions.

British attitudes, in a 2010 YouGov poll, were closer to play than belief. Sixty-one percent check their horoscope at least occasionally, 60% called horoscopes harmless fun, and 77% suspected they are vague statements presented so that they seem to apply to most people. Only 5% admitted letting a horoscope influence a decision. The public was split on the sign profiles themselves: 41% agreed that their star sign profile matches their personality, and exactly as many said it does not.

Why the description feels right

YouGov has tested this on both sides of the Atlantic. In its July 2017 survey of 1,148 US adults, each person was shown the description of their own sign: 66% agreed it described them accurately, and among the 95 Pisces in the sample, 71% did. The British poll of 2010 went a step further. Over 2,000 panelists were asked to rate the accuracy of their own star sign profile, and every one of them was shown the same text. Thirty-nine percent called it an accurate description of themselves, and 51% did not. The two polls differ in country, year and wording, so their figures cannot be compared directly, but the British one shows that a paragraph can fit roughly four in ten people regardless of birthday. It will fit a Pisces easily.

A second mechanism has been measured too: people who know their sign describe themselves slightly in line with it, as the Sagittarius page explains. The sign does not shape the person; knowing the sign shapes how the person answers a questionnaire. When Lu and colleagues tested 173,709 Chinese participants who took a Big Five personality inventory and gave their birthdates, sign, element (water included) and astrological gender, the "masculine" and "feminine" signs, predicted none of the five traits once birth season was allowed for. That held among those who said they believed in astrology.

Susan Blackmore and Marianne Seebold, in a 2001 paper in the astrology research journal Correlation, tested whether a horoscope changes a relationship. Forty-six women students received a personal horoscope with either positive or neutral love advice, and rated their relationships before and after, about six weeks apart. Scores did not change after the neutral advice and were slightly, not significantly, higher after the positive advice. Knowledge of and belief in astrology were high in the group, but very few said they would change their behavior because of a horoscope.

How the guidebooks rate Pisces

Geoffrey Dean's summary of six popular guidebooks reduces their compatibility ratings to angles. The books are warmest about a pairing at 60 or 120 degrees, or within the same sign; the 90 degree square is the classic bad aspect; the 180 degree opposition splits them two, two and two; and the 150 degree inconjunct has a single defender, Judy Hall. The table below groups the twelve Pisces pairings by the element of the other sign and gives the books' verdict. It records astrology's claims as Dean reports them, not findings and not advice.

Pisces withElementAspectGuidebook verdict
Pisces (same sign)watersame sign (conjunction)preferred
Cancerwatertrine, 120 degreespreferred
Scorpiowatertrine, 120 degreespreferred
Taurusearthsextile, 60 degreespreferred
Capricornearthsextile, 60 degreespreferred
Virgoearthopposition, 180 degreesbooks split evenly
Ariesfireneighbors, 30 degreesnot a preferred aspect
Sagittariusfiresquare, 90 degreesunfavorable by tradition
Leofireinconjunct, 150 degreesfavorable only in Hall
Aquariusairneighbors, 30 degreesnot a preferred aspect
Geminiairsquare, 90 degreesunfavorable by tradition
Libraairinconjunct, 150 degreesfavorable only in Hall
  • Pisces and Scorpio are a trine between two water signs, one of the aspects the guidebooks prefer.
  • Pisces and Gemini are a square between water and air, unfavorable by tradition.
  • Pisces and Virgo are opposite signs, the aspect on which the books give no common answer: two rate the opposition largely unfavorable, two average and two largely favorable. Dean also lists Virgo with Pisces among the pairings on which the columnists Russell Grant and Mystic Meg disagree.

None of it shows up in marriages. According to Dean's review, David Voas's analysis of 10,317,649 married couples in the 2001 census of England and Wales found, once recording errors were removed, no sign pairing that differed from chance. With a Swiss study of 358,763 couples and a French one of nearly 17 million, Dean counts 27 million couples and no sign effect.

If a Pisces mentions their sign

Read it as information about their interests, not their temperament. Pew found that 6% of Americans consult astrology, tarot or a fortune teller at least weekly and 14% monthly, and that most people who use them at all say they do it for fun. A useful follow-up is "do you take it seriously, or is it just for fun?" The answer predicts how much they will want to talk about compatibility, and nothing about how a Pisces will treat you.

Frequently asked questions

What is it like dating a Pisces?
Astrology calls Pisces, roughly February 20 to March 20, a mutable water sign, and Wikipedia's keywords for water are emotion, empathy and sensitivity. In a 2020 study by Jackson Lu and colleagues, 173,709 people took a Big Five personality inventory, and neither sign nor element predicted any of the five traits once birth season was allowed for, even among people who said they believed in astrology.
Which signs are most compatible with Pisces?
The guidebooks Geoffrey Dean compared favor the other water signs, Cancer and Scorpio (trines), and the earth signs Taurus and Capricorn (sextiles). Those are the books' claims. According to Dean's review of three marriage studies covering 27 million couples, no sign pairing married more often than chance.
Are Virgo and Pisces compatible?
They are opposite signs, and astrologers do not agree on oppositions: in Geoffrey Dean's comparison of six guidebooks, two rate them largely unfavorable, two average and two largely favorable. Dean also lists Virgo and Pisces among the pairings on which the columnists Russell Grant and Mystic Meg disagree.
Do people really believe in star signs?
Some do. In a Pew Research Center survey of 9,593 US adults in October 2024, 27% said they believe in astrology, including 43% of women aged 18 to 49. In a 2010 YouGov poll in Britain, 60% called horoscopes harmless fun and 5% said they had let one influence a decision.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia: Astrological sign Read October 8, 2026. Supports the sign order, approximate tropical dates, element, mode, classical and modern rulers, opposites and the keyword glosses for the elements and modes.
  2. Pew Research Center (May 21, 2025): 3 in 10 Americans consult astrology, tarot cards or fortune tellers Read October 8, 2026. Supports the US survey of 9,593 adults (October 2024): belief in astrology, the split by age and gender, frequency of use and reasons for use.
  3. YouGov (July 31, 2017): Do people agree with their own astrological description? Read October 8, 2026, with the full results tables linked from the article (1,148 US adults, July 24 to 25, 2017, weighted to all US adults). Supports the 66% of all adults and 71% of Pisces (95 respondents) who agreed that the description of their own sign fit them.
  4. YouGov (October 14, 2010): Stars in their eyes Read October 8, 2026. Supports the British horoscope attitudes and the experiment in which every panelist was shown the same star sign profile.
  5. Blackmore and Seebold (2001): The effect of horoscopes on women's relationships, Correlation 19(2) Read October 8, 2026 (authors' final draft). Supports the horoscope experiment on 46 women and the literature summary of Mayo, White and Eysenck (1978), Van Rooij (1994), Pawlik and Buse (1984) and Fichten and Sunerton (1983); those studies were not read in the original.
  6. Lu, Liu, Liao and Wang (2020): Disentangling stereotypes from social reality, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology Read October 8, 2026 (author-hosted PDF). Supports the Chinese stereotype table (Study 1b), the US comparison (Study 2), the Tantan dating app experiment (Study 4), the résumé experiment (Study 5), the test of 173,709 people on sign and the Big Five (Study 7) and the job performance test (Study 8).
  7. Geoffrey Dean: Love signs fail world's largest tests (N=27m) Read October 8, 2026. Dean's review of the Sachs, Castille and Voas marriage studies (27 million couples), his own calculations on Voas's tables (1.061 ratio, 0.2% excess, effect sizes), his summary of six sun sign guidebooks and their aspect ratings, and the Goodman, Hall, Ptolemy, Grant and Mystic Meg quotations.