Scorpio dating: the reputation, the pairings, the data
Scorpio's reputation, what a test of 173,709 people found, how guidebooks rate Scorpio pairings such as Virgo, and where the Sun really is.
Scorpio dating comes with a reputation. In horoscope terms, people born between about October 24 and November 22 are emotional, strong-willed and hard to move: a water sign in the fixed mode, ruled classically by Mars. The research suggests the reputation does more work than the birthday. A study of 173,709 people found that sign predicted none of the Big Five personality traits once birth season was allowed for, while experiments in the same paper show that people act on what they think a sign means. This page sets out the claims, what happens when a stereotype meets a large sample, and how the guidebooks rate the Scorpio pairings people look up, Scorpio with Virgo above all.
What the Scorpio horoscope claims
Wikipedia's chart of the Western signs lists Scorpio as the eighth sign, water in the fixed mode, ruled classically by Mars and, since the 20th century, by Pluto, with Taurus as its opposite. Water carries the keywords emotion, empathy and sensitivity, and the fixed mode resistance to change, great willpower and inflexibility. The combination is easy to turn into the stock Scorpio: feels deeply, holds on, does not bend. A scorpion in the name adds the sting.
You can see the sting in a 2020 study of Chinese attitudes to the signs by Jackson Lu and colleagues. Asked to list adjectives for each sign, Chinese participants gave "venomous" (26% of the adjectives, synonyms included) and "vindictive" (16%) as the most common words for Scorpio. The authors argue that sign stereotypes in China are largely explained by how the signs' names were translated, and that such stereotypes then affect how people are treated. One of the paper's references is a 2011 report in the Telegraph headlined "China job ads discriminate against Scorpio and Virgo".
The picture in the US is different. The same paper ran a comparison with 495 native English speakers in the US, on the reasoning that English sign names carry no everyday meaning. Asked which sign is most negatively judged in American society, 58.6% said they were unsure, against 32.1% in China, and the most common pick, at 7.7%, was Cancer, possibly, the authors suggest, because of the disease. In this paper, Scorpio's sting is a Chinese stereotype, not an American one. Belief itself is a minority view in the US: a 2025 Pew Research Center report, based on 9,593 adults surveyed in October 2024, found that 27% believe in astrology, 35% of women and 18% of men.
When the stereotype meets a large sample
Lu's team took 173,709 Chinese participants aged 18 to 60, who completed a 40-item personality inventory and gave their birthdate, and tested whether any of the twelve signs differed on agreeableness, conscientiousness, emotional stability, openness or extraversion. None did. Element and astrological gender did not predict the traits either, so water signs, Scorpio among them, were no more emotional than the rest. A faint link between sign and extraversion turned out to come from birth season and disappeared once season was controlled for. No sign scored higher than the other eleven on its own stereotyped adjective. A separate test of 32,878 people found that sign did not predict job performance either. The result held for believers, who made up 55% of a subset of 17,373 participants who were asked.
A Scorpion for a week
The sky is less dramatic than the stereotype. Using the constellation boundaries the International Astronomical Union fixed in 1930, the Illinois astronomer Jim Kaler gives the average date on which the Sun enters each one. The Sun is in Libra from November 1, enters Scorpius on November 24, and moves on into Ophiuchus on November 30. It spends about six days in front of the constellation named Scorpius, and those days fall after the horoscope's Scorpio season has ended. During the season itself the Sun is in front of Virgo for the first week and Libra for the rest, in line with the comparison table in Wikipedia's zodiac article. The signs are equal 30-degree slices of the Sun's path counted from the March equinox, not the constellations.
Scorpio pairings in the guidebooks
The guidebooks' logic is geometric. In Geoffrey Dean's summary of six of them, signs at 60 or 120 degrees from Scorpio, and Scorpio itself, are harmonious partners; signs at 90 degrees are not; and the 150 degree inconjunct has only Judy Hall in favor. Scorpio's opposite sign, Taurus, is where the books part company: on the opposition Dean found two of them largely unfavorable, two average and two largely favorable. The table, sorted from the books' warmest verdict to their most divided, is a summary of their claims as Dean reports them, not a finding and not advice.
| Scorpio with | Aspect | Elements | Guidebook verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scorpio (same sign) | same sign (conjunction) | both water | preferred |
| Virgo | sextile, 60 degrees | water and earth | preferred |
| Capricorn | sextile, 60 degrees | water and earth | preferred |
| Cancer | trine, 120 degrees | both water | preferred |
| Pisces | trine, 120 degrees | both water | preferred |
| Libra | neighbors, 30 degrees | water and air | not a preferred aspect |
| Sagittarius | neighbors, 30 degrees | water and fire | not a preferred aspect |
| Aries | inconjunct, 150 degrees | water and fire | favorable only in Hall |
| Gemini | inconjunct, 150 degrees | water and air | favorable only in Hall |
| Leo | square, 90 degrees | water and fire | unfavorable by tradition |
| Aquarius | square, 90 degrees | water and air | unfavorable by tradition |
| Taurus | opposition, 180 degrees | water and earth | books split evenly |
Scorpio and Virgo are two signs apart (the sign between them, Libra, has its own page), a sextile between water and earth, so the guidebooks rate the pairing favorably. Marriage records are the test of that rating. The American evidence is small: as Geoffrey Dean reports it, a 1971 study by B. I. Silverman found no departure from chance in 478 US divorces and 1,586 marriages, although a second sample of 1,382 marriages showed a small surplus of sextiles and trines, an effect size of 0.06. The European samples are far larger. Didier Castille counted the days between the birthdays of nearly 17 million French couples; Dean converted those counts into approximate sign distances, a conversion he calls far from exact, and found a small consistent deficit of squares but no consistent excess of sextiles or trines. In the UK, David Voas, working on 10,317,649 married couples in the 2001 census of England and Wales, found that once errors from guessed and imputed birthdays were removed, couples' signs were distributed as chance would predict. Scorpio and Virgo do not stand out.
If the reputation worries you
Treat the sign as a prompt, not an answer. Jealousy, intensity and secrecy are real ways in which people differ, and they are better judged by what someone does than by a birthday. Attachment research, for example, scores people on anxiety and avoidance in close relationships, which we cover in attachment styles in dating. Behaviors that deserve attention in anyone are covered in red flags in a relationship. Nothing in the Scorpio chart replaces that.
Frequently asked questions
What is it like dating a Scorpio?
Are Virgo and Scorpio compatible?
Which signs are most compatible with Scorpio?
Is the Sun in Scorpius during Scorpio season?
Sources
- Wikipedia: Astrological sign Read October 8, 2026. Supports the sign order, approximate tropical dates, element, mode, classical and modern rulers, opposites and the keyword glosses for the elements and modes.
- Lu, Liu, Liao and Wang (2020): Disentangling stereotypes from social reality, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology Read October 8, 2026 (author-hosted PDF). Supports the Chinese stereotype table (Study 1b), the US comparison of 495 American participants (Study 2: 58.6% unsure which sign is most negatively evaluated, against 32.1% in China; Cancer the most picked at 7.7%), the Tantan dating app experiment (Study 4), the résumé experiment (Study 5), the test of 173,709 people on sign and the Big Five (Study 7) and the job performance test (Study 8).
- Pew Research Center: 30% of Americans Consult Astrology, Tarot Cards or Fortune Tellers (May 21, 2025) Read October 8, 2026. Survey of 9,593 US adults, October 21 to 27, 2024: 27% believe in astrology (29% in 2017), 28% consult astrology or a horoscope at least yearly, women more likely than men to believe (35% against 18%).
- Jim Kaler: A Quick Guide to the Celestial Sphere (University of Illinois) Read October 8, 2026. Supports the average dates on which the Sun enters each constellation under the 1930 IAU boundaries, and Ophiuchus as an unofficial thirteenth zodiac constellation (Sun enters November 30).
- Wikipedia: Zodiac Read October 8, 2026. Supports the table comparing tropical, sidereal (Lahiri) and IAU constellation dates, the Babylonian constellation names and the effect of precession.
- Geoffrey Dean: Love signs fail world's largest tests (N=27m) Read October 8, 2026. Dean's review of the Sachs, Castille and Voas marriage studies (27 million couples) and of Silverman's 1971 US sample, his own calculations on Voas's tables (1.061 ratio, 0.2% excess, effect sizes), his summary of six sun sign guidebooks and their aspect ratings, and the Goodman, Hall, Ptolemy, Grant and Mystic Meg quotations.
- David Voas (2007): Ten million marriages: A test of astrological 'love signs', University of Manchester (archived copy) Read October 8, 2026 (Wayback Machine copy of the paper on the Manchester CCSR site). Supports the 10,317,649 couples in England and Wales, the 22,100 same-sign excess, the January 1 and July 1 counts, the 0.5% imputation rule, the cleaned sample of 9,500,773 and the conclusion of a random distribution.