Dating advice, checked against the research

First date tips: how long, what to say, who pays

How long a first date should last, how to greet, what to ask and who pays, with US and British YouGov polls and research on conversation.

The Mocha team6 min read

Keep a first date to an hour or two somewhere either of you can leave, ask questions that pick up what the other person has just said, and offer to pay or split. That covers most of what matters. Two of the questions people ask most, how long a first date should last and how to greet someone, have no poll behind them that we could find, so those answers are our judgment. The rest draws on YouGov polls of American and British adults and on research into how conversations between people who have just met actually go.

How long should a first date last?

Plan for an hour to an hour and a half, and build in a way to keep going. A coffee or one drink with the option of a walk afterward beats a three-course dinner reservation: either of you can extend the first in one sentence, and the second cannot be left early without a scene. American adults lean the same way. When YouGov asked 1,123 US adults in November 2017 which one place was most appropriate for a first date, half (50%) picked a casual restaurant, 13% an attraction you can walk around, such as a zoo, aquarium or museum, and 12% a coffee shop. Only 3% chose an expensive restaurant.

There is one piece of evidence for keeping it short. Boothby and colleagues found that after talking with someone new, people systematically underestimated how much their partner had liked them, and the gap held in conversations of varying lengths. Those were get-to-know-you conversations, not dates, so the finding is borrowed. Still, it means your own verdict at the end of the evening ("I talked too much, they looked bored") is the least reliable data you have, and a date that ends while it is still going well costs you nothing. Our page on texting after the first date follows the same study into the morning after.

Greeting: make it easy for both of you

Hugs, a kiss on the cheek, a handshake and a wave are all normal, and the right one depends on the pair. Two things take the guesswork out:

  • In your last message before meeting, say where you will be and what you are wearing: "I'll be at the table by the window, green jacket."
  • Follow their lead. A smile and "Hi, I'm Sam" is never wrong, and if they go in for a hug, hug back. If you wanted a hug and they offered a wave, waving has cost you nothing.

Arrive on time. If you are going to be more than five minutes late, text before you are late, not when you walk in.

The conversation: the next question is in their last answer

Huang and colleagues at Harvard found that people who ask more questions, follow-up questions in particular, are better liked, and that speed daters who asked more follow-ups got more yeses to a second date. The detail of those studies, and a table of questions sorted by the follow-up each one opens, is on our page of first date questions.

In practice: say they mention three days in Buffalo for work. "What's your favorite movie?" ignores it. "Three days in Buffalo in January, did you see the sun at all?" uses it. And answer your own questions when it is your turn. A run of questions with nothing from you back feels like an interview, which the same authors flag as a possible risk, though they did not test it.

Money: offer, and accept an offer

In the US, YouGov asked 1,123 adults on November 7 and 8, 2017, who should pay when a man and a woman are on a first date at a bar or restaurant. The top answers were the man (35%) and whoever asked the other person out (32%), while 15% said split the bill evenly and 9% said each pays for what they ordered. Women put whoever asked first, at 37%. For a first date between two men or two women, about half chose whoever asked (48% and 47%). Offense runs both ways: 37% would be offended if their date asked them to pay half, but 53% would be offended if their date assumed they would be paying the whole bill, including 76% of women. The median amount people thought right to spend on a first date was $50, though 40% gave no figure.

In the UK, YouGov asked 1,699 British adults on September 6 and 7, 2016, to imagine that someone had asked them out and chosen the place. Just over half (53%) picked the relaxed answer: they would not expect the other person to pay for everything, but would not be offended if they were not asked to contribute. Only 7% would expect them to pay for everything and be offended if asked to contribute, while 14% would be offended if they were not asked to contribute. The same poll found that 12% would be offended if a date asked them to pay half, against 48% who would be offended if a date did not offer to pay some or half.

Both polls are old and asked different questions, but they point the same way: offering costs you less than not offering. When the check comes, reach for your card, say "Can I get this one?" or "Want to split it?", and take the answer at face value. Our page on who pays on a first date breaks those figures down further and adds a German poll.

What to leave out

Our judgment, from the evidence above:

  • Your phone on the table. If you are on call or waiting for news, say so in the first minute and put it face down.
  • A plan that only works if the date goes well, such as a two-hour reservation with a deposit.
  • Questions about exes, salary or exactly where they live. Ask what they are into, not what they are worth.
  • Drinking more than you normally would to calm your nerves.
  • Deciding in the first ten minutes. Interest is easy to misread in both directions, as we explain in signs someone likes you.

Safety and the end of the evening

Meet at the venue rather than being picked up, tell a friend where you will be and when you expect to be home, and get home your own way. The full list is in the first date safety checklist.

When it ends, say what you feel. "I had a really good time tonight, I'd like to do this again" is clear, and so is "I've enjoyed meeting you, but I don't think we're a match." Wording for a no is in saying no without ghosting.

Frequently asked questions

How long should a first date last?
No poll or study we could read gives a number. Our judgment is an hour to an hour and a half, with an easy way to keep going, such as a walk or a second drink. Research on conversations finds that people underestimate how much the other person liked them, so ending while it is going well does no harm.
How should you greet someone on a first date?
We found no survey on this. Say where you will be and what you are wearing in your last message, arrive on time, smile and say your name, and follow their lead on a hug, a kiss on the cheek or a wave.
What should you not do on a first date?
Our judgment, since no study ranks first date mistakes: keep your phone away, do not quiz them about exes or money, avoid booking something long and fixed, and do not decide in the first ten minutes how it is going. Interest is easy to misread.
Who pays on a first date?
There is no single rule. In YouGov's 2017 US poll, 35% said the man should pay and 32% said whoever asked, and 53% would be offended if a date assumed they would pay the whole bill. In YouGov's 2016 British poll, 48% would be offended if a date did not offer to pay some or half. Offering to pay or split is the safer move.

Sources

  1. Boothby, Cooney, Sandstrom and Clark (2018), The liking gap in conversations: do people like us more than we think?, Psychological Science (Europe PMC record) Read October 8, 2026. Abstract only. Supports people underestimating how much conversation partners liked them, the effect appearing in the laboratory, among dorm mates and in workshops, persisting across conversations of varying length and lasting for several months.
  2. Huang, Yeomans, Brooks, Minson and Gino (2017), It doesn't hurt to ask: question-asking increases liking, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (Harvard Business School copy) Read October 8, 2026. Full text read. Supports the finding across three studies that people who ask more questions, particularly follow-up questions, are better liked, the speed dating result that a higher follow-up rate predicted agreement to a second date, people not anticipating that question-asking increases liking, and the authors' speculation that questions without reciprocal disclosure may reduce liking.
  3. YouGov US (November 16, 2017), 40% of men think men should always pay the bill on a first date, with the full results tables (YouGov NY, Paying On Dates) Read October 8, 2026, together with the linked results PDF. Supports the sample of 1,123 US adults, weighted, fieldwork November 7 and 8, 2017; for a first date between a man and a woman at a bar or restaurant: the man should pay 35% (men 40%, women 29%), whoever initiated the date 32% (women 37%), split evenly 15%, each pays for what they ordered 9%; whoever initiated 48% for a date between two men and 47% between two women; offended if asked to pay half 37% (women 49%, men 24%); offended if the date assumed they would pay the whole bill 53% (women 76%, men 28%); a median appropriate first date spend of $50 with 40% saying they did not know; and the most appropriate location: a casual restaurant 50%, an attraction such as a zoo, aquarium or museum 13%, a coffee shop 12%, an expensive restaurant 3%.
  4. YouGov UK (2016), Women are still happy to be bought dinner on a first date, with the full results tables for 1,699 GB adults (fieldwork September 6 and 7, 2016) Read October 8, 2026. Full results tables read, together with the article at yougov.com/en-gb/articles/16412. Supports the 1,699 GB adult sample and fieldwork dates, 12% offended if a date asked them to pay half, 48% offended if a date did not offer to pay some or half (77% of women, 18% of men), and the question on a date where the other person suggested the place: 7% expecting them to pay everything and offended if asked to contribute, 53% not expecting it and not offended either way, 14% offended if not asked to contribute. The tables contain no question on first date duration or greetings.